WSDA Wins Appeal Against Board of Denturists on Abutments
WSDA has secured an important legal victory in our challenge to a 2024 rule adopted by the Washington State Board of Denturists that allowed licensed denturists to place prefabricated implant abutments.
Throughout the rulemaking process, WSDA joined DQAC, the Washington State Society of Prosthodontists, and other oral health professionals in raising serious concerns about the rule, including concerns about patient safety, scope of practice and the Board of Denturists’ rulemaking process. Those concerns were largely ignored.
WSDA Took Action
With the support of the WSDA Board of Directors, we filed a legal challenge in Thurston County Superior Court. After the Superior Court initially sided with the Board of Denturists, WSDA appealed the decision to the Washington State Court of Appeals, Division Two.
The Court of Appeals Ruled in WSDA's Favor
The court found that the Board of Denturists failed to follow required rulemaking procedures under the Regulatory Fairness Act in adopting WAC 246-812-462, the rule permitting denturists to place prefabricated implant abutments.
The court wrote: “Because the Board failed to substantially comply with the significant legislative rule requirements and failed to demonstrate how it was exempt from the requirements of the RFA, we conclude that the Board did not comply with rule-making procedures.”
Why WSDA Challenged the Rule
Our legal challenge was based on three principal arguments:
- The rule improperly expanded denturists’ scope of practice. WSDA argued that a prefabricated implant abutment does not meet the statutory definition of a removable dental appliance. Because the Legislature determines the legal scope of practice for health care providers, WSDA argued that the Board of Denturists lacked authority to expand that scope through rulemaking.
- The rule created patient-safety concerns. While abutment placement can be straightforward, significant complications may arise. WSDA argued that denturists do not receive sufficient training to recognize and manage the range of potential complications associated with the placement of implant abutments.
- The Board failed to follow required rulemaking procedures. WSDA argued that the Board did not properly demonstrate the need for the rule, did not conduct additional public process after changing proposed rule language, and failed to comply with requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act and Regulatory Fairness Act.
The Court of Appeals resolved the case on the third argument and therefore did not decide WSDA’s scope-of-practice or patient-safety arguments. Those arguments remain open and may become important if the Board of Denturists attempts to pursue the policy again.
What Happens Next
The Board of Denturists must now determine its next step. It could seek further review of the court’s decision, begin a new rulemaking process, or choose not to pursue the issue further.
At its regularly scheduled November 6 meeting, the Board of Denturists held a 45-minute executive session regarding the litigation. No information about that discussion has been publicly released.
You can read a copy of the legal filing here.
This is an important victory for WSDA, organized dentistry and the patients Washington dentists serve. It is also a reminder of why a strong state dental association matters. When the practice of dentistry, patient safety or the profession’s interests are at stake, WSDA is prepared to act.
We are relentless advocates for Washington dentists, and we are proud to share this win with our members.
Questions? Contact WSDA Executive Director Bracken Killpack at bracken@wsda.org.
![]()
Dr. Brittany Dean
WSDA President